Sometimes You Have to Say No to Your Users

By Josh Catone
We teamed up with SiteGround
To bring you the latest from the web and tried-and-true hosting, recommended for designers and developers. SitePoint Readers Get Up To 65% OFF Now

“The customer is not always right. The truth is you have to sort out who’s right and who’s wrong for your app,” advises 37signals in their book Getting Real. “If you try to please everyone, you won’t please anyone.” In order to create the software you want to create, you sometimes have to say no to your users.

Video hosting site Vimeo did just that yesterday. Lauded as one of the “classiest” video hosting sites on the web, Vimeo announced on its blog yesterday that it would no longer be accepting video game videos, including walk-thrus, strategy videos, game demos, etc. (Machinima-style videos are excluded) and will be deleting clips that fall into that category on September 1.

The post caused a mixed reaction on their site, but a large number of the nearly six hundred comments expressed disappointment with the decision. Vimeo cited three reasons for the decision to nix game videos. First, they’re generally larger and cause longer transcoder wait times for other users (the single biggest reason for slow transcoding times, says Vimeo, has been game videos). Second, they open the site up to potential liability issues that they’re rather not deal with. And finally, they don’t match the mission statement of the site. “Vimeo was created with the intent of inspiring creativity and providing a place to share video with friends and family,” writes Vimeo. “The Vimeo staff does not feel that videos which are direct captures of video game play truly constitute ‘creative expression.'”

A comparison of video sites by Webware in February found that Vimeo had one of the slowest transcoding times on the web. It also has some of the best quality, which may cause slower transcoding, but slow transcoding wait times have obviously been an issue.

However, clearly, the main issue here was about the site’s focus — it seems obvious that Vimeo just doesn’t want to become known as a game video host. “We feel this decision will benefit Vimeo in the long run and better benefit the video makers it was created for,” said Blake Whitman of Vimeo. “Our resources are limited and they must be channeled towards maintaining our goals.”

At a conference I attended last fall, Jason Fried of 37signals advanced the idea that software development needs a leader willing to say “no.” Vimeo is following Fried’s theory of “opinionated software:” Figure out your vision and run with it — don’t always let your customers define your application. If some of your users want to take your app in a different direction, you don’t have to let them. Just tell them “no.” (Note: I argued an alternate view on ReadWriteWeb in February.)

We teamed up with SiteGround
To bring you the latest from the web and tried-and-true hosting, recommended for designers and developers. SitePoint Readers Get Up To 65% OFF Now
  • Ryan

    Eh!? I’ve seen hundreds of creative videos captured from within game (NOT Machinima-style videos).

  • I generally disagree with 37 signals, but I agree with them regarding this.

    Know your market, and cater to them. With 99.9% of us not making Google-level money, we all have limited resources, and those resources should be channeled towards the site’s intended market.

  • Klas

    The reasoning to do with creative expression is quite poor and comes across as nothing more than a sore excuse.

    Just look at the impact videos such as Red vs. Blue have had on the greater community. If it’s not creative then what is it?

  • Dan

    Clearly the legal angle is the main internal drive behind this, but trying to chalk it up to questions of creative expression obviously makes them sound less soulless. Not that I have a problem with it, its their site, they can do what they want with it, but I can never understand why companies feel the need to lie, or at least try to mislead people about stuff like this. I’d have much more respect if they just said “hey, we don’t wanna get sued” no shame in that, that’s a legitimate business concern.