I’m a Designer: How Do I Deal with a Cease and Desist Letter?
Few things are more stressful for a web designer than receiving a cease and desist letter. A cease and desist (C&D for the cool kids) is a notification that basically tells the recipient (i.e., you) to stop some activity or action that violates the rights of the sender. So if you have a trademark that looks suspiciously like a competitor’s, they might issue you a cease and desist.
What, then, should you do if you receive one? There are some actions you can take beyond just calling an attorney (and then being on the hook for pricey legal fees). To best protect yourself, your work, and your wallet, be sure to take these tips into account.
1. Stay calm
The first thing most people do when they get a C&D is get angry or upset. Being dragged into a legal battle is enough to rattle anyone, but you can’t overreact. Besides the fact that overreacting to any situation is a recipe for failure, responding poorly to a cease and desist could land you in some hot water down the road.
Remember that it might not be so serious. It could be a matter of miscommunication or mistaken identity or a very minor fix. And maybe they’re being really nice about it, like Jack Daniels is when people copy their label.
Finally, it could be an unscrupulous little ploy by a competitor to trick you into making a mistake or pulling a dominant product. If this is the case, you’ll need a clear head to see things through, which brings us to our next tip.
2. Analyze the situation
Obviously, you need to assess the validity of the C&D’s claim. Ask yourself, “what is the context?” Do they have a point? Even if your initial reaction is to be dismissive and defensive, sleep on it, and look at the claim again. Maybe your logo does look an awful lot like theirs. Perhaps you pulled code from somewhere you thought was public, but it turns out it wasn’t. If there is any degree of validity to the claim, acknowledge it, at least to yourself.
Don’t, however, just toss a C&D in the trash. Ignoring one can end up hurting a lot worse – you could get sued, and if you do, your indifference to a legitimate claim will be noted by lawyers and judges alike. Even if the claim seems to be frivolous, you ought to take it seriously.
3. Talk to a lawyer and do research
Okay, so we are going to recommend you talk to a lawyer. “But, why don’t I just do that in the first place?” you might ask. Because you have better things to spend your money on than legal fees for activities you could have just done yourself. You probably don’t need a lawyer to tell you if a C&D is frivolous.
Still, a lawyer will help you with the most important steps:
- If you’ve judged the claim as frivolous, they might disagree and provide a fresh perspective and plenty of experience.
- They can help you organize your documentation and point you in the right direction in terms of research regarding the claim.
- An attorney can guide you through the always complicated legal process.
- They will help you plan your response whether it be to deny, comply, or negotiate the claim.
Your head is in the right place, you’ve considered the claim, and you have solid legal counsel. The time has come to respond. You have four basic choices:
This is generally your optimal situation, especially if the cease and desist has a legitimate claim. We’ve harped on how expensive legal fees can be, but the cost of trial is even worse. Settling is going to save everyone time and money, both you and the claimant. Besides, there is often room for compromise.
You could respond and tell them they’re wrong. With this route, you’re acknowledging they’ve made a claim, but you’re essentially telling them to drop it, because you don’t plan on complying and don’t think you should have to. If they are being underhanded and see that you’re taking things seriously, at this point they’ll likely drop their claim, but if they’re serious it could mean the beginning of a drawn out process.
This is the simplest option. Just do what they ask and let it be, especially if they caught you using their product or property without permission. Also consider compliance if the claim is minor – say its referring to an old image or a page with little traffic. Even if they’re wrong, who cares? If the claim is bad, of course defend yourself, but make sure that the defense is worth the effort.
Issue your own cease and desist – or sue first
You could find that they actually have copied your intellectual property – say their claim was that your logo looked strikingly similar to theirs, but it ends up being coincidental and you find your site was published first. You may have a better claim, and by issuing your own C&D it could put you in a better negotiating position.
Or, if you’re feeling especially rambunctious, you could just dial it up a notch and sue them first. This strategy is especially effective if the C&D was meant as a ruse – they’ll settle immediately and you’ll probably find yourself with some extra cash. However, remember how expensive trial can be, so only go this route if you’re 100% certain the claimant is bluffing.
Unless you’re a lawyer, all things courtroom-related are an awful, soul-sucking distraction from the important work you’re doing. So instead of wasting more time than necessary bickering with competition or filing miles of paperwork, get smart and respond forcefully to a cease and desist claim. It’s worth it to address it wisely and head on.