I have been kicked out of Facebook!

Sure, I am not ! But what am I left with ?

Let’s clear up your doubt, :smiley: , indeed their pockets are deeper than mine but I am betting on the fact that a Chilean judge would love to make Chilean laws respected and have a go against GAFAM’s companies. Freedom of speech is a pretty touchy subject around here. It only takes a little touch of luck, FYI under the Chilean justice system, it is a judge who decides the verdict. There is no jury system here.

I know my chance are slim, if any. And by the way: can the terms of service (TOS) of a company supersede a country’s law? Surely, they cannot, can they?
(Read my answer to @Gandalf above)

Hi Corobori

The wording on my side has also changed a bit. But I have very less hope. I was temporarily banned from IG but got it back. I dont know why, after the review, I dont even use IG.
I agree with other that you might lose the case but if there is any consumer group or any other forum it might be helpful to raise the voice.
Another recent information: previously, FB never had this but now their website is saying they will give you 5 warnings unless you have seriously violated the community guidelines. In our case we never got the warning which is a somewhat a good ground.

Perhaps there is hope after all…

https://www.foxnews.com/tech/georgia-man-sues-facebook-wins-platform-denied-access-account-personal-photos-report

2 Likes

I know my chances are slim, but I am currently preparing the material and will talk to a lawyer hopefully soon. Even though I feel I am losing time, I prefer that and have a go and not regret it. A couple of them have been my customers for years, so we are on pretty good terms. I trust that they will honestly inform me about my chances in that matter. On top of that, on a previous opportunity, we bartered services, to soften my bill.

Where did you see the text about the 5 warnings?

Thank you for the article. For those who won’t read it: the guy had a warning and eventually got locked out of his account. After having tried all possible ways to get some human attention he sued. And nothing happened. As Facebook’s legal team did not respond to the lawsuit, the judge ordered them to pay $50.000, and eventually the guy got his access restored, but he hasn’t seen a dime yet.

2 Likes

I am having a preliminary conversation with a lawyer and I am trying to gather more cases that went to court similar to the one @benanamen mentioned.
I searched around and found some references such as this one or this one where I read that “Stewart (a lawyer) says they’ve been 100 per cent successful in reinstating their clients’ accounts, but acknowledges it’s a costly process that can take months.”. I created an alert to know about new cases if anybody finds other please let me know thru this topic

FWIW I have contacted the Australian lawyer mentioned in the article linked in my previous post.

In regard to my question about their success rate, here is their response:

Thank you for reaching out to us. We’re sorry to hear that you are dealing with this terrible Facebook hack.

We have had 100% success in convincing Facebook to restore the disabled accounts of our clients who have been victim of the same hack that you have experienced. However, the process is quite involved and requires us to prepare lengthy statutory declarations evidencing clients’ identity, location, business identity and reputation, and relevance of Facebook to social / business identity. We also must note that despite our success with previous clients, we cannot guarantee that Facebook will agree to restore your account.

Facebook also requires that all correspondence regarding issues like this be sent by mail, in the post, to California. That is what we consider to be a deliberate obstacle to clients seeking redress.

If you would like to engage this firm to act on your behalf, we can assist. The cost of these matters is fixed at AUD$3,300 inclusive of GST.

I then asked them if they were going thru court or directly to Facebook and if they received any information regarding the reason behind the account being blocked. Here is their answer:

Each Facebook issue can be unique. The majority we deal with are where the account has been “hacked” and an inappropriate image posted. We have had matters where our clients do not know the exact reason for their account being suspended, however that has not seemed to make a difference when having the account reinstated.

We do not deal with law enforcement, we deal directly with Facebook’s attorneys and Facebook administration is copied in to all correspondence.

We generally do not receive any response from either the attorney’s nor Facebook, unless they require further information. Usually the account is just reinstated and the first we know about it is when our client calls us to thank us. We believe that this is something Facebook do on purpose.

We can request information from Facebook in regard to why your account was suspended but based on past experience we would not be hopeful of an answer.

We understand your reticence to engage us with no assurance that this could happen again. I can say we have had a number of commercial clients who retain commercial accounts with Facebook and have had the same issue. They have not experienced any repeat (as yet) since their accounts were reinstated, and that has been over a number of years.

The quoted fee is for a simple matter and we may need to revise any fees based on your individual circumstances. If you are interested in instructing us please send through details of how you use your account (commercial or private), whether you advertise through Facebook and the circumstances of your account being suspended. Once we have that information we would be able to give you a more informed estimate of costs.

If you have any other questions or would like a short chat with one of our commercial team please do not hesitate to get back in touch.

So, is it worth AUD3,300 to employ the lawyer?

That is the question I am debating!

1 Like

It would probably be a lot cheaper and faster to just start a new page.

Hi,

Facebook doesn’t allow this Facebook is a community where people use their authentic identities. It’s against the Facebook Community Standards to maintain more than one personal account. extract from this page

So I reckon it wouldn’t be a good idea to make an effort to set up a new account and have it blocked once again, and this time for something that I truly did.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.