The Right Way to Make a Dropdown Menu

Share this article

Good and bad usability in menu navigation

There’s been a lot talk on SitePoint recently about dropdown menus, and not all of it entirely accurate. So I felt the need to chip-in and set the record straight on matters of best-practice, when it comes to JavaScript menus in all their forms.

First, let’s look at the key issues that impact on good usability:

  • mouseover-driven menu should have timers that delay their opening and closing. Open-timers mean that casual mouse movement doesn’t trigger menus when they’re unwanted. Close-timers mean that if your mouse momentarily slips-off or moves outside a menu, it doesn’t close abrubtly. And a synchronised combination of the two means that you can move your mouse from one link to another without triggering other menus as you pass over intervening links
  • menus should be able to reposition on-the-fly, so that if they approach or go over the edge of the window, they shift or invert position to avoid this
  • menus must be navigable by keyboard actions alone. Being able to tab through the links and have child-menus open sequentially is acceptable; being able to navigate with the arrow keys is ideal

Now those three things together make the difference between a menu that is functionally useable, and a menu that is disastrously unuseable and a nightmare for users to deal with. All three of these things need scripting to implement, and that brings me onto the next crucial questions of implementation and fallback content:

  • the top-level links of a menu should link to pages which provide access to all the same content, so that everything which was accessible from the menu is also accessible without it. The top-level links are the core content of a menu; the submenus are a progressive enhancement
  • if scripting is not available, menus cannot be made decently useable, and therefore should not work at all — do not use pure-CSS menu triggers

Pure CSS menus are an interesting proof of concept, but that’s all they are. Eric Meyer’s invention of them led the way to our re-thinking how menus should be built in the first place (before then, menus were all built with endless reams of document.written tables and divs; Eric showed how a semantic structure could be converted into a menu), but in of themseleves they are not suitable for real-world production use.

We also need to consider exactly how the show/hide mechanism of a menu should be implemented, in order to ensure accessibility to browser-based screenreaders:

  • menus should not be hidden with display, visibility, overflow or clip, as doing so also hides them from browser-based screenreaders. The correct approach is to use absolute positioning with a large negative left offset (so-called offleft positioning), which moves them off the screen and hence apparently invisible to sighted users, but does not remove them from the rendered output and therefore doesn’t affect assistive devices

Finally, there are details of the content of menus themselves, and the finer points of design that make for a better user experience:

  • a dropdown menu is not a sitemap; it should not link to every page of a site
  • a single menu shoud not contain more links than can fit above the fold and should not require the user to scroll
  • the menu links, or preferably the entire menu structure, should scale with font size
  • the rollover state of menu links should persist down the tree, so that a user can see at a glance the path through the structure to where they are now

Before I finish, I’ll make one more point about styles and types of menu. So-called mega menus are not different from what we know as dropdown menus. They have different content and styling in the submenus, and that’s all. Jakob Neilson’s recent piece on the subject has muddied the water by implying that this type of menu is inherently more useable and accessible, but that simply isn’t true. To prove his point he’s comparing aspects of good mega menus with aspects of bad conventional dropdown menus, which is not a fair or scientific comparison, because he’s not comparing like with like. His arguments fall flat when you compare with a well implemented dropdown.

In this short post I hope I’ve clarified what it takes to make a menu, that is useable, accessible, and built with the principles of progressive enhancement in mind. And to illustrate, here are two demos that exemplify all of these points:

You can also download both examples

These menus, incidentally, are straight out of SitePoint’s JavaScript Anthology, and are fully documented in Chapters 15 and 16, which as you’d probably guess, I wrote!

James EdwardsJames Edwards
View Author

James is a freelance web developer based in the UK, specialising in JavaScript application development and building accessible websites. With more than a decade's professional experience, he is a published author, a frequent blogger and speaker, and an outspoken advocate of standards-based development.

Share this article
Read Next
Digital Transformation with AI: The Benefits and Challenges
Digital Transformation with AI: The Benefits and Challenges
Priyanka Prajapat
Quick Tip: Creating a Date Picker in React
Quick Tip: Creating a Date Picker in React
Dianne Pena
How to Create Interactive Animations Using React Spring
How to Create Interactive Animations Using React Spring
Yemi Ojedapo
10 Reasons to Love Google Docs
10 Reasons to Love Google Docs
Joshua KrausZain Zaidi
How to Use Magento 2 for International Ecommerce Success
How to Use Magento 2 for International Ecommerce Success
Mitul Patel
5 Exciting New JavaScript Features in 2024
5 Exciting New JavaScript Features in 2024
Olivia GibsonDarren Jones
Tools and Strategies for Efficient Web Project Management
Tools and Strategies for Efficient Web Project Management
Juliet Ofoegbu
Choosing the Best WordPress CRM Plugin for Your Business
Choosing the Best WordPress CRM Plugin for Your Business
Neve Wilkinson
ChatGPT Plugins for Marketing Success
ChatGPT Plugins for Marketing Success
Neil Jordan
Managing Static Files in Django: A Comprehensive Guide
Managing Static Files in Django: A Comprehensive Guide
Kabaki Antony
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best React Website Builder
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best React Website Builder
Dianne Pena
Exploring the Creative Power of CSS Filters and Blending
Exploring the Creative Power of CSS Filters and Blending
Joan Ayebola
How to Use WebSockets in Node.js to Create Real-time Apps
How to Use WebSockets in Node.js to Create Real-time Apps
Craig Buckler
Best Node.js Framework Choices for Modern App Development
Best Node.js Framework Choices for Modern App Development
Dianne Pena
SaaS Boilerplates: What They Are, And 10 of the Best
SaaS Boilerplates: What They Are, And 10 of the Best
Zain Zaidi
Understanding Cookies and Sessions in React
Understanding Cookies and Sessions in React
Blessing Ene Anyebe
Enhanced Internationalization (i18n) in Next.js 14
Enhanced Internationalization (i18n) in Next.js 14
Emmanuel Onyeyaforo
Essential React Native Performance Tips and Tricks
Essential React Native Performance Tips and Tricks
Shaik Mukthahar
How to Use Server-sent Events in Node.js
How to Use Server-sent Events in Node.js
Craig Buckler
Five Simple Ways to Boost a WooCommerce Site’s Performance
Five Simple Ways to Boost a WooCommerce Site’s Performance
Palash Ghosh
Elevate Your Online Store with Top WooCommerce Plugins
Elevate Your Online Store with Top WooCommerce Plugins
Dianne Pena
Unleash Your Website’s Potential: Top 5 SEO Tools of 2024
Unleash Your Website’s Potential: Top 5 SEO Tools of 2024
Dianne Pena
How to Build a Chat Interface using Gradio & Vultr Cloud GPU
How to Build a Chat Interface using Gradio & Vultr Cloud GPU
Vultr
Enhance Your React Apps with ShadCn Utilities and Components
Enhance Your React Apps with ShadCn Utilities and Components
David Jaja
10 Best Create React App Alternatives for Different Use Cases
10 Best Create React App Alternatives for Different Use Cases
Zain Zaidi
Control Lazy Load, Infinite Scroll and Animations in React
Control Lazy Load, Infinite Scroll and Animations in React
Blessing Ene Anyebe
Building a Research Assistant Tool with AI and JavaScript
Building a Research Assistant Tool with AI and JavaScript
Mahmud Adeleye
Understanding React useEffect
Understanding React useEffect
Dianne Pena
Web Design Trends to Watch in 2024
Web Design Trends to Watch in 2024
Juliet Ofoegbu
Building a 3D Card Flip Animation with CSS Houdini
Building a 3D Card Flip Animation with CSS Houdini
Fred Zugs
How to Use ChatGPT in an Unavailable Country
How to Use ChatGPT in an Unavailable Country
Dianne Pena
An Introduction to Node.js Multithreading
An Introduction to Node.js Multithreading
Craig Buckler
How to Boost WordPress Security and Protect Your SEO Ranking
How to Boost WordPress Security and Protect Your SEO Ranking
Jaya Iyer
Understanding How ChatGPT Maintains Context
Understanding How ChatGPT Maintains Context
Dianne Pena
Building Interactive Data Visualizations with D3.js and React
Building Interactive Data Visualizations with D3.js and React
Oluwabusayo Jacobs
JavaScript vs Python: Which One Should You Learn First?
JavaScript vs Python: Which One Should You Learn First?
Olivia GibsonDarren Jones
13 Best Books, Courses and Communities for Learning React
13 Best Books, Courses and Communities for Learning React
Zain Zaidi
5 jQuery.each() Function Examples
5 jQuery.each() Function Examples
Florian RapplJames Hibbard
Implementing User Authentication in React Apps with Appwrite
Implementing User Authentication in React Apps with Appwrite
Yemi Ojedapo
AI-Powered Search Engine With Milvus Vector Database on Vultr
AI-Powered Search Engine With Milvus Vector Database on Vultr
Vultr
Understanding Signals in Django
Understanding Signals in Django
Kabaki Antony
Why React Icons May Be the Only Icon Library You Need
Why React Icons May Be the Only Icon Library You Need
Zain Zaidi
View Transitions in Astro
View Transitions in Astro
Tamas Piros
Getting Started with Content Collections in Astro
Getting Started with Content Collections in Astro
Tamas Piros
What Does the Java Virtual Machine Do All Day?
What Does the Java Virtual Machine Do All Day?
Peter Kessler
Become a Freelance Web Developer on Fiverr: Ultimate Guide
Become a Freelance Web Developer on Fiverr: Ultimate Guide
Mayank Singh
Layouts in Astro
Layouts in Astro
Tamas Piros
.NET 8: Blazor Render Modes Explained
.NET 8: Blazor Render Modes Explained
Peter De Tender
Mastering Node CSV
Mastering Node CSV
Dianne Pena
A Beginner’s Guide to SvelteKit
A Beginner’s Guide to SvelteKit
Erik KückelheimSimon Holthausen
Brighten Up Your Astro Site with KwesForms and Rive
Brighten Up Your Astro Site with KwesForms and Rive
Paul Scanlon
Which Programming Language Should I Learn First in 2024?
Which Programming Language Should I Learn First in 2024?
Joel Falconer
Managing PHP Versions with Laravel Herd
Managing PHP Versions with Laravel Herd
Dianne Pena
Accelerating the Cloud: The Final Steps
Accelerating the Cloud: The Final Steps
Dave Neary
An Alphebetized List of MIME Types
An Alphebetized List of MIME Types
Dianne Pena
The Best PHP Frameworks for 2024
The Best PHP Frameworks for 2024
Claudio Ribeiro
11 Best WordPress Themes for Developers & Designers in 2024
11 Best WordPress Themes for Developers & Designers in 2024
SitePoint Sponsors
Top 9 Best WordPress AI Plugins of 2024
Top 9 Best WordPress AI Plugins of 2024
Dianne Pena
20+ Tools for Node.js Development in 2024
20+ Tools for Node.js Development in 2024
Dianne Pena
The Best Figma Plugins to Enhance Your Design Workflow in 2024
The Best Figma Plugins to Enhance Your Design Workflow in 2024
Dianne Pena
Harnessing the Power of Zenserp for Advanced Search Engine Parsing
Harnessing the Power of Zenserp for Advanced Search Engine Parsing
Christopher Collins
Build Your Own AI Tools in Python Using the OpenAI API
Build Your Own AI Tools in Python Using the OpenAI API
Zain Zaidi
The Best React Chart Libraries for Data Visualization in 2024
The Best React Chart Libraries for Data Visualization in 2024
Dianne Pena
7 Free AI Logo Generators to Get Started
7 Free AI Logo Generators to Get Started
Zain Zaidi
Turn Your Vue App into an Offline-ready Progressive Web App
Turn Your Vue App into an Offline-ready Progressive Web App
Imran Alam
Clean Architecture: Theming with Tailwind and CSS Variables
Clean Architecture: Theming with Tailwind and CSS Variables
Emmanuel Onyeyaforo
How to Analyze Large Text Datasets with LangChain and Python
How to Analyze Large Text Datasets with LangChain and Python
Matt Nikonorov
6 Techniques for Conditional Rendering in React, with Examples
6 Techniques for Conditional Rendering in React, with Examples
Yemi Ojedapo
Introducing STRICH: Barcode Scanning for Web Apps
Introducing STRICH: Barcode Scanning for Web Apps
Alex Suzuki
Using Nodemon and Watch in Node.js for Live Restarts
Using Nodemon and Watch in Node.js for Live Restarts
Craig Buckler
Task Automation and Debugging with AI-Powered Tools
Task Automation and Debugging with AI-Powered Tools
Timi Omoyeni
Quick Tip: Understanding React Tooltip
Quick Tip: Understanding React Tooltip
Dianne Pena
12 Outstanding AI Tools that Enhance Efficiency & Productivity
12 Outstanding AI Tools that Enhance Efficiency & Productivity
Ilija Sekulov
React Performance Optimization
React Performance Optimization
Blessing Ene Anyebe
Introducing Chatbots and Large Language Models (LLMs)
Introducing Chatbots and Large Language Models (LLMs)
Timi Omoyeni
Migrate to Ampere on OCI with Heterogeneous Kubernetes Clusters
Migrate to Ampere on OCI with Heterogeneous Kubernetes Clusters
Ampere Computing
Scale Your React App with Storybook and Chromatic
Scale Your React App with Storybook and Chromatic
Daine Mawer
10 Tips for Implementing Webflow On-page SEO
10 Tips for Implementing Webflow On-page SEO
Milan Vracar
Create Dynamic Web Experiences with Interactive SVG Animations
Create Dynamic Web Experiences with Interactive SVG Animations
Patricia Egyed
5 React Architecture Best Practices for 2024
5 React Architecture Best Practices for 2024
Sebastian Deutsch
How to Create Animated GIFs from GSAP Animations
How to Create Animated GIFs from GSAP Animations
Paul Scanlon
Aligning Teams for Effective User Onboarding Success
Aligning Teams for Effective User Onboarding Success
Himanshu Sharma
How to use the File System in Node.js
How to use the File System in Node.js
Craig Buckler
Laravel vs CodeIgniter: A Comprehensive Comparison
Laravel vs CodeIgniter: A Comprehensive Comparison
Dianne Pena
Essential Tips and Tricks for Coding HTML Emails
Essential Tips and Tricks for Coding HTML Emails
Rémi Parmentier
How to Create a Sortable and Filterable Table in React
How to Create a Sortable and Filterable Table in React
Ferenc Almasi
WooCommerce vs Wix: Which Is Best for Your Next Online Store
WooCommerce vs Wix: Which Is Best for Your Next Online Store
Priyanka Prajapati
GCC Guide for Ampere Processors
GCC Guide for Ampere Processors
John O’Neill
Navigating Data Management: Warehouses, Lakes and Lakehouses
Navigating Data Management: Warehouses, Lakes and Lakehouses
Leonid Chashnikov
Integrating MongoDB with Node.js
Integrating MongoDB with Node.js
Dianne Pena
How to Use Node.js with Docker
How to Use Node.js with Docker
Craig Buckler
4 Reasons Why You Should Join A Freelancing Community
4 Reasons Why You Should Join A Freelancing Community
Kyle Prinsloo
ChatGPT vs AutoGPT: Comparing Top Language Models
ChatGPT vs AutoGPT: Comparing Top Language Models
Dianne Pena
How to Perform User Authentication with Flask-Login
How to Perform User Authentication with Flask-Login
Yemi Ojedapo
BERT vs LLM: A Comparison
BERT vs LLM: A Comparison
Dianne Pena
Monitoring Your Python App with AppSignal
Monitoring Your Python App with AppSignal
Connor James
BabyAGI vs AutoGPT: A Comprehensive Comparison
BabyAGI vs AutoGPT: A Comprehensive Comparison
Dianne Pena
Top Redux Alternatives: Exploring State Management Solutions
Top Redux Alternatives: Exploring State Management Solutions
Dianne Pena
Code Migration: Ampere Porting Advisor for x86 to AAarch64
Code Migration: Ampere Porting Advisor for x86 to AAarch64
Pete Baker
React Router v6: A Beginner’s Guide
React Router v6: A Beginner’s Guide
James Hibbard
Get the freshest news and resources for developers, designers and digital creators in your inbox each week