Yoda-speak as a model for language design

Share this article

In his blog on MSDN, Microsoft software design engineer Matt Warren has proposed “Yoda-speak” as a useful model for designing more natural programming languages. Matt has been one of the main drivers behind the evolution of the C# language. Though C# 2.0 is still awaiting its official release in Visual Studio 2005, the design of C# 3.0 is already complete, and Matt is looking to the horizon for what comes next in programming language design. One of the main features in this upcoming version is Language Integrated Query (LINQ), which aims to provide all the power of database queries in general programming languages. Here’s an example of LINQ in action from Microsoft’s LINQ overview:



string[] names = { "Burke", "Connor", "Frank", 
                   "Everett", "Albert", "George", 
                   "Harris", "David" };

IEnumerable <string> expr = from s in names 
                           where s.Length == 5
                           orderby s
                           select s.ToUpper();

foreach (string item in expr)
  Console.WriteLine(item);

The trick, of course, is in assigning expr a value using syntax that resembles an SQL database query. This syntax, however, will be built right into C# 3.0 (among other .NET languages), and fully supported by the next major version of Visual Studio. One mildly controversial difference between SQL and LINQ syntax is the appearance of ‘from’ ahead of ‘select’. In SQL, you nominate the action you want to perform (e.g. SELECT) before indicating where you want to perform this action (FROM) and how (WHERE). LINQ reverses this in a bid to describe queries in a way that is more natural for human beings. Matt argues that this transition can (and will) be carried into the rest of the language, and this will be the innovation that characterizes the next wave of programming language redesign. His point gets a little lost, I feel, due to his poor command of Yoda-speak, but some of the examples put forward in the comments to his post hint at the potential. Of course, Perl has had some of this almost since birth, and has gained a reputation for being needlessly cryptic as a result. From the Perl syntax documentation:
Many of Perl’s syntactic elements are optional. Rather than requiring you to put parentheses around every function call and declare every variable, you can often leave such explicit elements off and Perl will figure out what you meant. This is known as Do What I Mean, abbreviated DWIM. It allows programmers to be lazy and to code in a style with which they are comfortable.
Can current .NET languages like C# and VB.NET make the transition to the ostensibly more natural “Yoda ordering”, or will Microsoft–as Matt suggests–have to create YODA the Programming Language from scratch?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Yoda Speak and Language Design

What is Yoda Speak and how does it differ from standard English?

Yoda Speak, also known as Yodish, is a unique style of speech patterned after the character Yoda from the Star Wars franchise. Unlike standard English which follows a Subject-Verb-Object (SVO) sentence structure, Yoda Speak typically uses an Object-Subject-Verb (OSV) structure. This inversion of sentence structure creates a distinct and memorable speech pattern that is immediately recognizable to Star Wars fans.

How can I learn to speak like Yoda?

Learning to speak like Yoda involves understanding and practicing the unique sentence structure he uses. Start by inverting the order of your sentences from Subject-Verb-Object to Object-Subject-Verb. For example, instead of saying “I am going to the store,” you would say “To the store, I am going.” Practice with different sentences until you become comfortable with this new structure.

Are there any tools or resources to help me learn Yoda Speak?

Yes, there are several online tools and resources available to help you learn Yoda Speak. These include online translators that can convert standard English sentences into Yoda Speak, as well as tutorials and guides that provide tips and tricks for mastering this unique language style.

Can Yoda Speak be used as a model for language design?

Yoda Speak can indeed serve as an interesting model for language design. Its unique sentence structure challenges conventional language rules and encourages creativity and flexibility in communication. However, it’s important to note that Yoda Speak is a fictional language and may not be suitable for all contexts, especially formal or professional settings.

What are some examples of Yoda Speak?

Some classic examples of Yoda Speak include phrases like “Do or do not, there is no try,” and “Fear is the path to the dark side.” These phrases showcase the unique sentence structure and philosophical tone that characterize Yoda Speak.

Is Yoda Speak a real language?

While Yoda Speak is a distinct and recognizable speech pattern, it is not considered a real language. It is a fictional language created for the Star Wars franchise. However, it does have consistent rules and structure, which makes it possible to learn and use.

Can I use Yoda Speak in my writing?

Yes, you can use Yoda Speak in your writing for creative or humorous effect. However, because it deviates from standard English, it may not be appropriate for formal or professional writing.

How can I translate a sentence into Yoda Speak?

To translate a sentence into Yoda Speak, you typically invert the sentence structure from Subject-Verb-Object to Object-Subject-Verb. However, there are also online translators available that can do this for you.

Why is Yoda Speak popular?

Yoda Speak is popular because it is associated with the beloved character Yoda from the Star Wars franchise. Its unique sentence structure and philosophical tone also make it memorable and distinctive.

Can learning Yoda Speak improve my understanding of language structure?

Yes, learning Yoda Speak can help improve your understanding of language structure by challenging you to think about sentence construction in a new way. It can also enhance your creativity and flexibility in communication.

Kevin YankKevin Yank
View Author

Kevin Yank is an accomplished web developer, speaker, trainer and author of Build Your Own Database Driven Website Using PHP & MySQL and Co-Author of Simply JavaScript and Everything You Know About CSS is Wrong! Kevin loves to share his wealth of knowledge and it didn't stop at books, he's also the course instructor to 3 online courses in web development. Currently Kevin is the Director of Front End Engineering at Culture Amp.

Share this article
Read Next
Get the freshest news and resources for developers, designers and digital creators in your inbox each week