If in doubt use Helvetica (fall back on Arial for Windows) and Georgia for the body, or Georgia for the titles and Verdana for the body.
The combination of serif / sans-serif; title / body, or vise-versa works well and the fonts above work particularly well on the web medium which is why you see them everywhere.
Also as well be careful of your contrast. The paragraph under “York wedding photographer davidclick.com” is difficult to read because it sits over the photo.
Assuming all fonts are available, the first will be picked. Though, say Trebutchet MS isn’t available, it would then look to Arial, by some twist in fate, that isn’t available, it’d look to Helvetica, etc etc.
Font still…sticks out too much. Too in my face, for me anyway.
Hey Ryan does a century gothic font family exist? In dreamweaver - (yes I can here your disgust across the pond) it doesnt pick up a font family with gothic
Make a stack ( a selection of fonts from what you want to what available). Even if you picked a good font, it could be your that viewers ONLY have helvetica. It is possible (and actually quite easy) to make a great design with only web-safe fonts, perhaps the issue is not so much the font but the lack of font-weight and size modulation ( not everything HAS to be bold, 18px type…lol)