Can a combination of dictionary words be trademarked?

I run a web site and would like to trademark a combination of three words that are being used in the domain name. The three words are found in the dictionary.

Questions:

1 - Can the three words be trademarked?

2 - Once trademarked, can other sites still use those three words in their domain names?

I’m guessing the words can’t be trademarked, but I am looking for thoughts on this.

Thanks

Companies usually deliberalely mis-spell one of the words in order to be able to trademark it

for example Google instead of googol and Dor instead of door.

You don’t need to misspell a word to trademark and yes, dictionary words can be trademarked.

Let’s take a look at the words that Apple claims trademarks on according to their website.

Apple
Aqua
Bonjour
Boot Camp
Capitals
Carbon
Chicago
Cocoa
Exposé
Gadget
Instruments
Key chain
Keynote
Logic
Monaco
Newton
New York
Numbers
Pages
Panther
Photo Booth
Quartz
Retina
Safari
Sand
Snow Leopard
Soundtrack
Spaces
Spotlight
Techno
Tiger
Time Capsule
Time Machine

source: http://www.apple.com/legal/trademark/appletmlist.html

Keep in mind that these trademarks are for very specific areas. For example, time capsule refers to “wireless hard drive/Wi-Fi base station” so they can’t run out and sue a company that uses the term time capsule to sell actual time capsules.

Hope that helps.

IANAL

and not necessarily enforceable. Even where a trademark is enforceable it only applies to the country(s) where it is registered.

There seems to be a lot of confusion over trademarks. Whether the word appears in a dictionary or not has almost zero to do with trademark law.

Below I have put a short primer on trademarks for your reading pleasure.

WHAT IS A TRADEMARK?
A trademark includes any word, name, or symbol used in commerce to identify and distinguish the goods of one seller from goods sold by others, and to indicate the source of the goods. In short, a trademark is a brand name. (If a service provider wishes to brand their product it is called a Service Mark and enjoys the same protection as a Trademark.)

The law considers a trademark to be a form of intellectual property. Proprietary rights in relation to a trademark may be established through actual use in the marketplace, or through registration of the mark with the United States Patents and Trademarks Office (USPTO). There is no requirement to register a trademark, but federal registration has several advantages including notice to the public of the registrant’s claim of ownership of the mark, a legal presumption of ownership nationwide, and the exclusive right to use the mark on or in connection with the goods.

HOW ARE TRADEMARK RIGHTS ACQUIRED?
Rights to a trademark can be acquired in one of two ways: (1) by being the first to use the mark in commerce; or (2) by being the first to register the mark with the USPTO.

You do not need a lawyer to file an application with the USPTO for a registered trademark. You may conduct a search free of charge on the USPTO website using the Trademark Electronic Search System at http://tess2.uspto.gov/bin/gate.exe?f=login&p_lang=English&p_d=trmk . You may file your trademark application online using the Trademark Electronic Application System http://www.uspto.gov/teas/index.html to fill out an application form and then submit the application directly to the PTO over the internet with payment by credit card.

HOW ARE TRADEMARK RIGHTS PROTECTED?
To protect a trademark through actual use requires the user to place a superscript TM after the Trademark TM. The owner of a registered trademark uses the symbol ® to indicate a Registered Trademark®.

Trademark owners may commence legal proceedings to prevent unauthorized use of their trademark under the Latham Act. While the level of protection for a registered trademark is greater than that of a common law trademark, any trademark owner may pursue their property rights and prevent the unauthorized use of their trademark by others. Factors affecting the owner’s rights include whether the trademark is registered, the similarity of the trademarks and the actual products, and whether the trademark is well known. The final test is always whether a consumer of the goods or services will be confused as to the identity of the source or origin.

Defendants in a trademark infringement suit can assert the affirmative defense of fair use. Fair use occurs when a descriptive mark is used in good faith for its primary, rather than secondary, meaning, and no consumer confusion is likely to result.

Courts can award damages in the form of both an injunction against further use of the trademark by the infringer and monetary compensation. An intention to deceive by an infringer will generally create higher damages.

HOW DOES TRADEMARK LAW PROTECT DOMAIN NAMES?
The domain name system was invented to allow internet users a way of accessing specific computers on the Internet through easily remembered names. Domain names have become a valuable property in today’s Internet economy. Consequently, trademark owners have been quick to use the courts when they feel others have taken domain names they are exclusively entitled to use.

In addition to existing trademark legislation, in 1999, congress passed the The Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (ACPA) to protect trademark owners from acts of cyber piracy by those who have bad faith intent in using a domain name to profit from another’s trademark.

There is now over fifteen years of case law concerning ownership rights in domain names, much of which is extremely fact specific. It has not been easy for the court system to fit the cyber world into existing Trademark law. However, once a court found a domain name registrant was acting in bad faith they found a reason to prevent the continued use of the domain by the registrant even if they had to create new trademark law reasons.

Recently, ICANN has developed a dispute resolution procedure as an alternative to filing suit for trademark owners. Again, whether the registrant acted in bad faith will be a large factor in the ultimate resolution.

As pointed out, common words can be trademarked. “Apple” is obviously a very common word but is trademarked by Apple Inc. for computers (and a whole bunch of other stuff). But there are several hundred other registered trademarks which include the word Apple. So just because you trademark three words does NOT mean that in all cases no one can ever use those three words in a domain. There certainly may be cases where the use would infringe on your mark, and could be stopped, but to make a blanket statement that the registration would prevent anyone from ever using the three words in a domain is way too broad.

I think it’s worth clarifying one of your points further Jaffe:

Generally speaking, when a trademark application is pending or if you are using a mark which remains unregistered you use the superscript TM to indicate that the brand name is being used explicitly as such and thereby may be subject to intellectual property protection, however once it’s been approved and registered then you move to the general purpose use registered trademark symbol. The difference is pretty subtle and most ordinary people are unlikely to understand the difference but the TM is only ever used on unregistered trademarks (as is to promote goods and services) rather than via actual use for an existing protected mark. :slight_smile:

In regards to the OP, as long as the mark is unique and cannot be otherwise confused, you should be able to trademark it regionally or internationally (as required).