Sitepoint Competition

I was unsure of where to place this, since there are no open threads on this subject and elsewhere might have this thread be lost, but yeah.

I was wondering if all entries will be posted after the contest? Or if it’s possible for entries to be all be posted now, and the community can just see the designs of all the individuals? What’s the judges views on that? I see no reason as to why they can’t be posted now, as their judging shouldn’t be tainted (well, actually they can if they point out stuff that is faulty and the judge wouldn’t have noticed).

If this is a stupid thread feel free to close.

Not stupid at all Ryan, fair question :slight_smile:

The entries will not be showcased right now, but rather at the end when all has been judged to avoid any bias.
Also we will ask everyone if they are okay with us publishing their entry before we do.

In the meantime, we will showcase some entries from staff members who joined just for fun. They will be put online somewhere today or tomorrow.

The Judges are very good believe me Ryan and that’s why it will take us a long while. We don’t want flooding with PM and opinionated public comments (regarding specific entries) until we have thoroughly analysed and scored all the submissions.

For the simple reason it may be considered trying to tamper with the Judge’s own integrity and we want a fair unbiased system for all entrants.

Like Remon said, we will also have to ask everyone whom submitted if they are willing to have their submission used within a special showcase.

I would assume you yourself would like to be included in such a gallery.

Why not have a judge open a thread then lock it?

Well I did put a lot of work into it and I’d like to see what others have to say about it, so yes I would be in that list :).

As I typed up this thread I thought about the bias viewpoint, and I do agree that the integrity needs to be kept in.

Thanks :).

Even if we opened a thread (before the results) and had it locked. Believe me (going from past personal experience) certain individuals would try to contact myself to gain favour. Also someone would mention the entries somewhere else within SPF - whether intentionally or not.

It is one of the reasons the other judges are not naming themselves. I take a no nonsense approach regarding such attempts anyway but it is beside the point.

You will just have to patently wait and hope we can get the powers that be to allow a showcase for the members that have given us permission when we publish the results. :slight_smile:

While I didn’t put an entry in, would people know you were a judge Robert - if this thread never happened?

Yes! I think they would know when it was running. I did say, I was JUDGEcoder:
Teaser: http://www.sitepoint.com/forums/showthread.php?t=727944
While it was running: http://www.sitepoint.com/forums/showthread.php?t=730215
Closed for Judging: http://www.sitepoint.com/forums/showthread.php?t=738237

I am the leading Judge so only I needed to be vocal; as I was law. :slight_smile:

haha my bad I didn’t see that one.

No worries. :slight_smile: