So, I run a jigsawpuzzle(jigsawpuzzlesnow.com) site now, about 2 years ago. But it seems Google needs sites to be older than that to even consider them. I make a jigsaw puzzle each day and distribute and many sites use my jigsaw puzzles(flash games), I get about 2000 pageviews from pure referral traffic from players. I get some Bing/Yahoo traffic but can't show up in google. I have webmaster tools running on the site and it reports no issues at all. I have never used any backlink methods so I do not think I am blacklisted. But if I searched "Jigsaw Puzzles Now", my site does not show up. My facebook page that links to my main site shows up on page 2 or something but my actual site is nowhere to be found. Google has indexed like 2000 pages of my site so I am sure I'm in the index, but yet I can't even get the site to show up if I search for the title?
As a side note, any sites that I have under 3-4 years old don't show up when I search for the title but sites I have older than 3-4 years will show up as #1 when I search the title. Anyone else notice this?