Google Lies: Just Write Good Content ... ********!

*********** = b u l l s h i t t :wink:

Google pretends that if you write good content, you will be seen and rank better that other websites.

This is an obvious counterproof:

I have setup a website and wrote a whooping 100+ articles during almost one year. When you search Rebol on Google:

You will see this single page on Rebol http://coolnamehere.com/geekery/rebol/

Whereas my site http://reboltutorial.com with hundreds of pages with thorough articles and linked even by the software editor itself (Carl Sassenrath the famous OS Amiga Architect) on http://rebol.com

cannot even be seen !

Conclusion: Google lies I am wasting my time better do something else :slight_smile:

you’re full of crap

search rebol tutorial and you’re number 1

search rebol and you’re number 11 (i.e. “cannot even be seen” is totally wrong)

please, stop your whining

:smiley:

Yeah I know of course since that’s my domain name, but I’m a scientist I wanna know why A SINGLE USELESS page on REBOL is outranking my website : why Google Algorithm so bad not to be able to distinguish the two :slight_smile:

This page has just a bunch of links, should I deduce that it’s better to spam the web with just links and I will have more chance to rank higher ? Will just take me 1/10th of my time to just write one single article on my website :frowning:

This page has just a bunch of links, should I deduce that it’s better to spam the web with just links and I will have more chance to rank higher ? Will just take me 1/10th of my time to just write one single article on my website

You don’t want to do that. Just keep writing unique AND optimized web pages and you’ll be ok. G will recognize you as an authority site if ppl start linking to you naturally.

I have already THE authority website (rebol.com) linking to me and others :slight_smile: That’s why this is an absurdity and I’m starting to understand better why there are so many blogs with poor article and bunch of links since google seems to like that kind of page.

I don’t want to put a link on every Rebol keyword with bold character on my site, this would just hurt the eyes, is it what you mean by optimizing :wink:

I mean on first page relatively with the one single page on Rebol, if that page wasn’t on first page I would understand.

You write a lot on these forums about how corrupt Google is and how they preach one thing and practice another, yet you fail to provide any evidence of your arguments. I’m not saying you’re wrong, just that it would be nice to have some sort of substance to your argument.

Its not about content, its about content that is good enough that your peers and readers “organically” link to, hence making your site popular on that particular subject.
So content is in fact king, if your market says it is, its not really up to you to decide.

Well said. You need both well written content and people interested enough in it to want to link to it to get to the top of the results.

In the case of the OPs’s site the page loaded so slowly to start with I almost gave up waiting for it to load and once it finished loading I wished that I had.

Good point on the page loading time.

Blech, 7 seconds on average to load the page. People aren’t going to hang around 7 seconds to read the page from a SERP so that is going to kill you from a quality score perspective.

I checked too and you can be seen. True, it is not 100% about content but you still do need it!

The content is popular on the subject for sure, I am linked from all Rebol sites.

That is not my question, it is as i you answer like a Robot :slight_smile:

My question is WHY a page with just LINKS can outrank a whole blog ?

YOU DON’T KNOW THE ANSWER ? THEN DON’T ANSWER SOME GENERALITIES, I KNOW THEM ALREADY THANKS.

Sure I can be seen on Google, that is NOT my question, my question is about the other SINGLE page with just LINKS.

If it is enough to just create a page with links then why bother creating a whole blog ?

Hear that newbies ? All the gurus can’t answer the questions, they fakely rationalize that it suffices to blah blah blah …

Don’t believe a word any more about all the mantras you can read: it’s just ******** like in stock market of marketers who want to sell their great seo “knowledge” whereas most don’t know much more than yourself.

That’s another problem I know, I have to look for another wordpress template but haven’t found a good one yet.

  1. Pages are ranked, not sites.
  2. They have more links than you do and links are the #1 factor in ranking pages (note that I said “pages” and not “sites”).
  3. Penalties are put in place for slow loading sites, your site loads like a snail after eating Christmas dinner.
  4. Perhaps Google doesn’t like your attitude.

If it is enough to just create a page with links then why bother creating a whole blog ?

Because a blog is a better information resource than a single page, and thus is more likely to get backlinks. It’s also about building a brand, which a single page cannot do.

With that said, I’ll be adding to you to my ignore list and hope that others do the same due to your attitude. You got the answer to your question many times, there is no need to be rude and to yell at people because you don’t like it.

Given how little you’ve told us about what keywords you think you should be ranking for it’s hard to put you straight. I did a search for ‘rebol tutorials’ and you were No 2 after Rebol themselves, with an indented listing no less so I have no idea why you think your site ‘can’t be seen’. You also ranked 5 for ‘rebol explanations’ and you probably rank for a whole bunch of stuff that frankly I can’t be bothered to find for you. You need to learn how to do keyword research among other things.

Google don’t lie, and whatever they do it’s always intended to benefit themselves and what benefits Google users benefits Google so you gotta think like Google, what do you want to show your users so that they come back and use Google again, something useful right? And how would you judge Usefulness if you were Google?

Figure that out and you’ve figured out SEO.

Why on earth do people read only 1/4 of a question sentence :slight_smile: My question wasn’t “Why can’t I been seen on Google” my question was :

Why can’t I been seen
1°) on first page of google
2°) for rebol keyword
3°) whereas a single page with very little content and mostly links can.

So can someone take into account the 3 premisces of the question before jumping on his keyboard :smiley:

YOU said it, a “single page page cannot”, in reality it can so my question. I’ve been major in maths and logics at school, it has always astounded me that my other fellows found logic difficult and this seem to continue : you are really irrational :smiley:

OK, in that case can you please provide the relevant information instead of this vague list of criteria. What’s the exact keyword phrase and which page is it that’s outranking you? Then we might have something to use to work out why you’re having the problem.

Is English your first language? I ask purely because if it isn’t I’ll take that into account when trying to understand your posts and work out whether or not you understood mine.

Perhaps you should have taken some remedial reading classes instead :wink:

It’s also about building a brand, which a single page cannot do.

A single page cannot build a brand (unlike a blog) is what I said, the statement has nothing to do with ranking in SERPs.

JJ I admire your persistence and patience but we’ve already explained, several times, why his pages are being outranked. He just doesn’t like the answer because it doesn’t back up his perceptions.

FYI When I do a search for Rebol, his site does show up on page 1 (listing 10 to be exact) and the other site does not. I guess the Google algo must be fixed now (geesh). Thank you Google engineers for reading this thread!