644-windows-logo

Windows 8.1: Back to Basics?

By | | Operating systems | Software | Usability

9

Microsoft has been in the news this week. While any publicity is better than none, the headlines and statements have been particularly scathing:

  • Windows 8 is Microsoft’s “New Coke” fiasco
  • Windows 8 sales slump is killing the PC industry
  • users are confused by Windows 8

Windows 8 was an ambitious project. The OS attempted to merge smart phone, tablet and desktop concepts into a cohesive experience. Microsoft should be applauded for trying something new but, in reality, Windows 8 is two OSs bundled as one.

Tami Reller, head of Windows Marketing and Finance, admitted:

the learning curve is definitely real

Few would disagree. I’ve been using the OS for seven months and, while it feels comfortable now, those initial weeks without a Start button were disorientating. Metro can be — and still is — quirky on a standard desktop PC, but I rarely use Metro apps other than the media player.

If you’re in the industry, you’re paid to use technology for its own sake; learning something new is part of the course. However, for most companies, technology is a tool which helps them achieve business objectives. Unless there are clear commercial benefits, the costs associated with changing that tool and retraining staff are prohibitive.

I suspect people new to PCs actually grasp Windows 8 concepts better than older versions of the OS (clicking Start to shut down was an obvious metaphoric breakdown). Unfortunately, most people have used Windows before; they can understand evolution but revolution is a different matter. Besides, if you absolutely must learn something new, why not try Mac OS or Linux?

Windows Blue

It’s impossible to determine figures but I’d be amazed if Windows 8 sales matched those of Windows 7. Fortunately, Microsoft has listened to user criticism.

Pre-release versions of the next version of the OS, codenamed Windows Blue, were leaked on to the web recently. Microsoft won’t make any public comments, but hinted a preview release could appear in June. Version 8.1 is the most likely name but many of us old hands will think of it as Service Pack 1.

The interface looks much the same, but the leaked OS offers a number of revised features…

An optional Start button
In my Windows 8 review I speculated:

I would not be surprised to see the Start button make a triumphant return

Windows 8 and Start button

I rarely miss the Start button now I’ve created appropriate taskbar shortcuts and use the keyboard Windows key to access the Start screen. The new logo-shaped Start button will probably do the same as the lower-left screen gesture, but having a button present will reassure many people.

Boot to desktop
Microsoft was criticized for showing the Start screen rather than the more familiar desktop after login. It’s a minor point since launching any standard application will instantly switch. That said, a new “boot to desktop” option will bring joy to many.

Configurable tile sizes
Start screen tiles are currently either “larger” or “smaller”. Even the small size doesn’t permit many icons on a desktop display so a new icon-sized tile will use a quarter of the space. Interestingly, a new super-sized option may also appear which could provide some interesting possibilities for live tiles.

New apps
Many of the existing Metro apps will be updated and a new video editing application could appear.

The OS should also include better SkyDrive integration. I’ve been impressed with Microsoft’s DropBox-like online file storage system and I suspect an increased number of applications will be SkyDrive-aware.

Internet Explorer 11
IE11 is a more exciting prospect although there’s no guarantee it’ll reach the final build. If expectations are correct, the new browser will fill the final missing gaps in IE10 — namely a few minor HTML5 features and WebGL (it’ll be interesting to hear how Microsoft engineers overcame the WebGL “security issues” they identified).

A long-overdue update to the F12 Developer Tools could also appear…

IE11 F12 Developer Tools

The current tools are adequate but clunky and ugly when compared with Firebug, the Webkit Inspector, Dragonfly or any other Microsoft development software. The company is enticing users back to IE but projects such as modern.IE a solid set of development tools will get developers on-side.

In summary, Windows 8 is changing but don’t expect it to revert back to Windows 7. Time will tell if the updates are enough to convince buyers.

Are you using Windows 8? Do you prefer it? Do you detest it? Do you want your Start button back? Will Windows 8.1 address your concerns?

Craig Buckler

Craig is a Director of OptimalWorks, a UK consultancy dedicated to building award-winning websites implementing standards, accessibility, SEO, and best-practice techniques.

More Posts - Website

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

PilotBob May 13, 2013 at 9:39 am

> Are you using Windows 8?

Yes.

> Do you prefer it?

Yes.

> Do you detest it?

No.

> Do you want your Start button back?

No.

> Will Windows 8.1 address your concerns?

not from what I have heard. My problems with windows 8 have nothing to do with the start button or the live tiles, it has to do with support for Windows 8 Store apps on a desktop machine. There is no windowed mode. There is no multi-monitor support. On a multi-monitor machine you can have the windows 8 “stuff” on one monitor or the other.

It might be fine on a 10inch table to only have 1 app visible (or two with snap view) at a time… but on a desktop with two 24+” monitors it is just too restrictive so I basically don’t run Windows Store apps on my desktop, although there are some I would like to use.

BOb

Reply

David Zhang May 13, 2013 at 9:35 am

hopefully microsoft will re-enable Aero…
metro design+aero effect… nice

Reply

Craig Buckler May 13, 2013 at 10:01 am

I don’t miss Aero. Yeah, it looked nice, but was a system hog and you didn’t notice it when you were working. I much prefer Win8′s fast booting!

Reply

Damon Johnson May 13, 2013 at 8:30 am

Hey, great article and at last one that is pretty balanced.

Personally, I don’t miss the start button as much as other people have. I actually find it easier to press the start button on my keyboard and start typing the application I want to run. I would go so far as to say that this is a far more efficient process that going through the motions of using a mouse.

I love the fluid look and feel of Windows 8, the only thing lacking is a store to rival apple as I find most apps basic and nothing new. Hopefully, as time goes on, developers will add to the store.

My only critic is that I find it awkward to navigate folders. I have solved this by creating a shortcut on my desktop and can navigate to folders this way. I feel that’s the only thing which has ‘slowed down ‘ working on my PC.

I’m not sure where the ‘hate for Windows eight’ has come from, but I definitely love it and think its a step in the right direction!

Reply

ac513 May 13, 2013 at 8:57 am

I’ve been doing this with the start menu’s search bar ever since Vista. I was under the assumption everyone took the app/file searching to their advantage, so the confusion with Windows 8 surprised me. I guess people missed the memo *7 years ago* that the start menu was quickly becoming antiquated.

Reply

Shaun May 13, 2013 at 8:24 am

Glad to see the start button is back… the start screen is missing a ton of functionality that the start menu contains.

IE11 would be great since IE10 has a lot if issues and as a developer the dev tools are pathetic! So glad these are getting fixed! The DOM Tree that IE had was horrible, incorrectly nested, didn’t do live updates and was a monster to try and use. I will not miss the old dev tools one bit!

Reply

Anonymous May 13, 2013 at 8:51 am

Sorry to disappoint you, but there is an important distinction here. Windows 8.1 is bringing back the “Start Button”, NOT the “Start Menu.” Craig correctly notes above that this new button behaves the same as the lower-left screen gesture. In other words, clicking on this start button brings you to the start screen, just like pressing the Windows key.

Reply

Craig Buckler May 13, 2013 at 10:06 am

To be fair, we won’t know until the final release. The Start menu shortcuts still lurk beneath Win8′s surface so it could be resurrected. Or it could present a smaller Start screen. Or it could show the full Start screen like it does in Blue. Doubt I’ll use it anyway!

Huy Phan May 13, 2013 at 8:07 am

On the next Beta Windows bring back Start and Shutdown in Start

Reply

Leave a Comment