Petition to move Reviews And Critiques

[sid egg]

I feel Reviews and Critiques should be moved in to the community center, and it should be open to a wider range of topics. Not just design/design elements, but usability, features, and just general site reviews.

[stymiee]

That forum is already for everything you mentioned.

[Saz]

Actually, the reviews forums did used to be in the Community Centre. They were moved because, not only was it felt that they were better suited to the web design side of the forums, but also being in the Community Centre put too much strain on the Community Team as they also had the MarketPlace forums to run. I was the Community Team's leader at the time and it was hard work moderating both sections. Plus, the Community Team has the newsletter to do as well now, so to give them the reviews forums back would be expecting too much of one team.

[vgarcia]

Not just design/design elements, but usability, features, and just general site reviews.

That's what the forum is for now. In some reviews I've done there I've specifically asked about things like usability and SEO over the look of a layout.

[sid egg]

That's what the forum is for now. In some reviews I've done there I've specifically asked about things like usability and SEO over the look of a layout.

Okay, fair enough, it's still in the design section.... :P

[Sarah]

actually its in the Design yrou Site section - which covers, HTML, XHTML, CSS and Graphics Design... therefore its open to more than just design elements.

It might be the descriptions of those forums that is putting you of